Ironic: Multiple compute host support

https://blueprints.launchpad.net/nova/+spec/ironic-multiple-compute-hosts

Today, the Ironic virt driver only supports a single nova-compute service. This is clearly not viable for an environment of any interesting scale; there’s no HA, everything fails if the compute service goes down. Let’s fix that.

Problem description

Computers are horrible things. They die sometimes. They crash processes at random. Solar flares can make bad things happen. And so on and so forth.

Running only one instance of nova-compute for an entire Ironic environment is going to be a bad time. The Ironic virt driver currently assumes that only one nova-compute process can run at once. It exposes all resources from an Ironic installation to the resource tracker, without the ability to split those resources out into many compute services.

Use Cases

This allows operators to avoid having a single nova-compute service for an Ironic deployment, so that the deployment may continue to function if a compute service goes down. Note that this assumes a single Ironic cluster per Nova deployment; this is not unreasonable in most cases, as Ironic should be able to scale to 10^5 nodes.

Proposed change

In general, a nova-compute running the Ironic virt driver should only register as a single row in the compute_nodes table, rather than many rows.

Nova’s scheduler should schedule only to a nova-compute host; the host will choose an Ironic node itself, from the nodes that match the request (explained further below). Once an instance is placed on a given nova-compute service host, that host will always manage other requests for that instance (delete, etc). So the instance count scheduler filter can just be used here to equally distribute instances between compute hosts. This reduces the failure domain to failing actions for existing instances on a compute host, if a compute host happens to fail.

The Ironic virt driver should be modified to call an Ironic endpoint with the request spec for the instance. This endpoint will reserve a node, and return that node. The virt driver will then deploy the instance to this node. When the instance is destroyed, the reservation should also be destroyed.

This endpoint will take parameters related to the request spec, and is being worked on the Ironic side here.[0] This has not yet been solidified, but it will have, at a minimum, all fields in the flavor object. This might look something like:

{
    "memory_mb": 1024,
    "vcpus": 8,
    "vcpu_weight": null,
    "root_gb": 20,
    "ephemeral_gb": 10,
    "swap": 2,
    "rxtx_factor": 1.0,
    "extra_specs": {
        "capabilities": "supports_uefi,has_gpu",
    },
    "image": {
        "id": "some-uuid",
        "properties": {...},
    },
}

We will report (total ironic capacity) into the resource tracker for each compute host. This will end up over-reporting total available capacity to Nova, however is the least wrong option here. Other (worse) options are:

  • Report (total ironic capacity)/(number of compute hosts) from each compute host. This is more “right”, but has the possibility of a compute host reporting (usage) > (max capacity), and therefore becoming unable to perform new build actions.

  • Report some arbitrary incorrect number for total capacity, and try to make the scheduler ignore it. This reports numbers more incorrectly, and also takes more code and has more room for error.

Alternatives

Do what we do today, with active/passive failover.

Doing active/passive failover well is not an easy task, and doesn’t account for all possible failures. This also does not follow Nova’s prescribed model for compute failure. Furthermore, the resource tracker initialization is slow with many Ironic nodes, and so a cold failover could take minutes.

Resource providers[1] may be another viable alternative, but we shouldn’t have a hard dependency on that.

Data model impact

None.

REST API impact

None.

Security impact

None.

Notifications impact

None.

Other end user impact

None.

Performance Impact

This should improve performance a bit. Currently the resource tracker is responsible for every node in an Ironic deployment. This will make that group smaller and improve the performance of the resource tracker loop.

Other deployer impact

A version of Ironic that supports the reservation endpoint must be deployed before a version of Nova with this change is deployed. If this is not the case, the previous behavior should be used. We’ll need to properly deprecate the old behavior behind a config option, as deployers will need to configure different scheduler filters and host managers than the current recommendation for this to work correctly. We should investigate if this can be done gracefully without a new config option, however I’m not sure it’s possible.

Developer impact

None, though Ironic driver developers should be aware of the situation.

Implementation

Assignee(s)

Primary assignee:

jim-rollenhagen (jroll)

Other contributors:

devananda jaypipes

Work Items

  • Change the Ironic driver to be a 1:1 host:node mapping.

  • Change the Ironic driver to get reservations from Ironic.

Dependencies

This depends on a new endpoint in Ironic.[0]

Testing

This should be tested by being the default configuration.

Documentation Impact

Deployer documentation will need updates to specify how this works, since it is different than most drivers.

History

None.