Virt driver pinning guest vCPU threads policies

Virt driver pinning guest vCPU threads policies

https://blueprints.launchpad.net/nova/+spec/virt-driver-cpu-thread-pinning

This feature aims to implement the remaining functionality of the virt-driver-cpu-pinning spec. This entails implementing support for thread policies.

Problem description

Some applications must exhibit real-time or near real-time behavior. This is general possible by making use of processor affinity and binding vCPUs to pCPUs. This functionality currently exist in Nova. However, it is also necessary to consider thread affinity in the context of simultaneous multithreading (SMT) enabled systems. In these systems, competition for shared resources can result in unpredictable behavior.

Use Cases

Depending on the workload being executed the end user or cloud admin may wish to have control over how the guest used hyperthreads. To maximise cache efficiency, the guest may wish to be pinned to thread siblings. Conversely the guest may wish to avoid thread siblings (i.e. only pin to one sibling) or even avoid hosts with threads entirely. This level of control is of particular importance to Network Function Virtualization (NFV) deployments which care about maximizing cache efficiency of vCPUs.

Project Priority

None

Proposed change

The flavor extra specs will be enhanced to support one new parameter:

  • hw:cpu_threads_policy=avoid|separate|isolate|prefer

This policy is an extension to the already implemented CPU policy parameter:

  • hw:cpu_policy=shared|dedicated

The threads policy will control how the scheduler / virt driver places guests with respect to CPU threads. It will only apply if the scheduler policy is ‘dedicated’

  • avoid: the scheduler will not place the guest on a host which has hyperthreads.

  • separate: if the host has threads, each vCPU will be placed on a different core. ie no two vCPUs will be placed on thread siblings

  • isolate: if the host has threads, each vCPU will be placed on a different core and no vCPUs from other guests will be able to be placed on the same core. ie one thread sibling is guaranteed to always be unused,

  • prefer: if the host has threads, vCPU will be placed on the same core, so they are thread siblings.

The image metadata properties will also allow specification of the threads policy:

  • hw_cpu_threads_policy=avoid|separate|isolate|prefer

This will only be honored if the flavor does not already have a threads policy set. This ensures the cloud administrator can have absolute control over threads policy if desired.

Alternatives

None.

Data model impact

None.

The necessary changes were already completed in the original spec.

REST API impact

No impact.

The existing APIs already support arbitrary data in the flavor extra specs.

Security impact

No impact.

Notifications impact

No impact.

The notifications system is not used by this change.

Other end user impact

No impact.

Support for flavor extra specs is already available in the Python clients.

Performance Impact

None.

Support for CPU policies already exists and this is merely an extension of that functionality.

Other deployer impact

The cloud administrator will gain the ability to define flavors with explicit threading policy. Although not required by this design, it is expected that the administrator will commonly use the same host aggregates to group hosts for both CPU pinning and large page usage, since these concepts are complementary and expected to be used together. This will minimize the administrative burden of configuring host aggregates.

Developer impact

It is expected that most hypervisors will have the ability to support the required thread policies. The flavor parameter is simple enough that any Nova driver would be able to support it.

Implementation

Assignee(s)

Primary assignee:

sfinucan

Work Items

  • Enhance the scheduler to take account of threads policy when choosing which host to place the guest on.

  • Enhance the scheduler to take account of threads policy when mapping vCPUs to pCPUs

Dependencies

None.

Testing

It is not practical to test this feature using the gate and tempest at this time, since effective testing will require that the guests running the test be provided with multiple NUMA nodes, each in turn with multiple CPUs.

These features will be validated using a third-party CI (Intel Compute CI).

Documentation Impact

None.

The documentation changes were made in the previous change.

References

Current “big picture” research and design for the topic of CPU and memory resource utilization and placement. vCPU topology is a subset of this work:

Current CPU pinning validation tests for Intel Compute CI:

Existing CPU Pinning spec:

History

Revisions

Release Name

Description

Liberty

Introduced

Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License

Except where otherwise noted, this document is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License. See all OpenStack Legal Documents.

nova-specs