Direct users mapping for federated authentication

bp federated-direct-user-mapping

Allow for specifying mapping rules where effective user exists in the backend. Otherwise treat as ephemeral users, members of service domain called Federated.

Problem Description

Today mapping engine assumes all effective users are ephemeral and intentionally does not do any database lookups. Many cloud providers want to use cloud federation so the authentication is handled by the first class Identity Provider, but the user exists in the Identity backend.

This problem is manifested in many ways, firstly when an ephemeral user obtains a token, the user section of the token does not have a ‘domain’ portion. This, breaks the API contract we established when obtaining tokens. Currently, consuming projects work around this issue by checking to see if ‘OS-FEDERATION’ is present in the token.

Proposed Change

Part of the change is adding a concept of a default federated domain. That is, all the ephemeral users (not present in the backend) will be stored in a default federated domain. The domain’s name will be immutable and will be named Federated.

Even though there are many users from many IdPs being placed in the default Federated domain, there is no collision between user ids and names, since the users do not exist in Keystone, and domains are a Keystone concept. The user’s token will provide information about the Identity Provider that was used to authenticate.

Mapping rules should be changed - cloud administrators should be able to specify the domain the user belongs to. If such an attribute is not specified explicitly, this will mean the user is meant to be ephemeral and automatically belongs to federated domain. If the domain is not present in the backend, server will respond with appropriate error code. If the domain attribute is specified and is present in the backend, server will do the user lookup and respond with an unscoped token. The token should be later scoped to a project or domain, depending on roles assigned to the user. Specifying additional groups in the mapping rules will not take any effect on roles the user has assigned to him. Domain can be identified either by id or name. Example of local rule specifying a domain in the user object:

"local": [
        "user": {
            "id": "{0}",
            "domain": {
                "id": "12de34"

In case the effective user is ephemeral, an unscoped federated token will be issued:

    "token": {
        "methods": [
        "user": {
            "id": "",
            "domain": {
                "name": "Federated"
            "name": "",
            "OS-FEDERATION": {
                "identity_provider": "ACME",
                "protocol": "SAML",
                "groups": [
                    {"id": "abc123"},
                    {"id": "bcd234"}

The proper way to distinguish whether the user is ephemeral or not is by checking by membership in the federated domain. If no domain information is provided, then it is assumed that the user is ephemeral and will use the default federated domain.

Proposed change also solves the issue of an inconsistent token being returned, (where the user didn’t have a domain) and there should be less special handling needed by clients/middleware.



Security Impact

Leveraging authentication to a first class Identity Provider can increase overall security.

Notifications Impact


Other End User Impact


Performance Impact

Federated workflow includes more HTTP calls to provide a token to an end user.

Other Deployer Impact


Developer Impact




Primary assignee:

Marek Denis (marek-denis)

Other assignees:

Steve Martinelli (stevemar) Guang Yee (gyee)

Work Items

  • Add logic for service domain Federated.

  • Mapping engine to properly handle domain keyword in the user object.

  • Adjust auth plugins to distinguish between ephemeral user authentication and existing user mapping.

  • In case of ephemeral user change the format of the unscoped tokens



Documentation Impact

All the changes must be reflected in the documentation.


Add a domain to federated users -