Deprecate the os-hosts API

https://blueprints.launchpad.net/nova/+spec/deprecate-os-hosts

Much of the os-hosts API is duplicated with the os-services and os-hypervisors APIs. Other parts are not implemented for all backends, or even a good idea for Nova to have in the compute API. Other parts are not even implemented for any backend anywhere. This spec proposes to deprecate the API altogether.

Problem description

The os-hosts and os-services APIs are very similar, and they work on the same resources (the services records in the nova database). Specifically PUT /os-hosts/{host_name} compared to PUT /os-services/disable and PUT /os-services/enable.

Both APIs allow you to list services and show details for a specific host (compute node).

The os-hosts and os-hypervisors APIs are also similar in that they work on the same resources (the compute_nodes records in the nova database). Specifically GET /os-hosts and GET /os-hosts/{host_name} compared to GET /os-hypervisors and GET /os-hypervisors/{hypervisor_id}.

Both APIs allow you to enable and disable a service so instances will not be scheduled to that service (compute host).

There are some additional action APIs that are specific to the os-hosts API:

  1. Putting the service (host) into maintenance mode. This is only implemented by the XenServer virt driver and despite the description in the support matrix 1 it has been reported that it does not actually evacuate all of the guests from the host, it just sets a flag in the Xen management console, and is therefore pretty useless. Regardless, we have other APIs that allow you to do the same thing which are supported across all virt drivers, which would be disabling a service and then migrating the instances off that host.

  2. Reboot host. This is only supported by the XenServer and Hyper-v drivers. This is also arguably something that does not need to live in the compute API. The backing drivers do no orchestration of dealing with guests in the nova database when performing a reboot of the host. The compute service for that host may be temporarily disabled by the service group health check which would take it out of scheduling decisions, and the guests would be down, but the periodic task which checks for unexpectedly stopped instances runs in the nova-compute service, which might be dead now so the nova API would show the instances as running when in fact they are actually stopped.

  3. Shutdown host. Same as #2 for reboot host.

  4. Start host. This is literally not supported by any in-tree virt drivers. The only drivers that implement the host_power_action method are XenServer and Hyper-v and they do not support the startup action. Since this is an RPC call from nova-api to nova-compute, you will at least get a 501 error response indicating it is not supported or implemented (even though 501 is the wrong response for something like this).

Use Cases

As an admin, I want to use a single, consistent API for managing services in my Nova deployment (os-services).

As an admin, I want to use a single, consistent API for managing compute nodes in my Nova deployment (os-hypervisors).

As a developer, I do not want to support duplicate APIs or things that should live outside of Nova, like code that reboots or stops an entire compute host or hypervisor. This is especially annoying in a multi-cell cells v2 world where we have to make sure there is a unique identifier in the API to target a unique resource in any given cell (see 2 for details).

Proposed change

In a microversion, deprecate all methods in the os-hosts API controller such that requests at that microversion or later will result in a 404 NotFound error.

Alternatives

None

Data model impact

None

REST API impact

With a new microversion, any requests at that microversion or later to the os-hosts API will result in a 404 NotFound response.

These are the specific APIs:

  • GET /os-hosts - list hosts

  • GET /os-hosts/{host_name} - show host details

  • PUT /os-hosts/{host_name} - update host status

  • GET /os-hosts/{host_name}/reboot - reboot host

  • GET /os-hosts/{host_name}/shutdown - shutdown host

  • GET /os-hosts/{host_name}/startup - start host

Also, yes, those GETs on the power action APIs are not a mistake, they are actually implemented as GETs.

Security impact

None

Notifications impact

None

Other end user impact

The following CLIs and their backing API bindings in python-novaclient will be deprecated and capped at the new microversion:

  • nova host-describe - superseded by nova hypervisor-show

  • nova host-list - superseded by nova hypervisor-list

  • nova host-update - superseded by nova service-enable/disable

  • nova host-action - no alternative within Nova by design

Performance Impact

None

Other deployer impact

Deployers that were relying on the os-hosts API for scripts will need to cap at the microversion or change to use os-services or os-hypervisors. If any Xen or Hyper-v admins were using the power action API, they will need to use something native to those hypervisors. Note when asking about usage of the API in the openstack-operators mailing list 3 no one said they were using this.

Developer impact

None

Implementation

Assignee(s)

Primary assignee:

Matt Riedemann (mriedem)

Other contributors:

None

Work Items

  • Add the new microversion to deprecate the os-hosts API methods.

  • Cap and deprecate the related CLIs and APIs in python-novaclient.

  • Cap, replace or remove any usage of the os-hosts API in Tempest.

Dependencies

None

Testing

Unit tests and in-tree functional tests as normal.

There are some tests in Tempest which rely on the os-hosts API either directly for testing the API or indirectly for listing hosts for other test setup, like with aggregates or live migration testing. The host list and show operations can be replaced with the os-hypervisors or os-services APIs. The enable/disable/reboot/shutdown/start APIs in os-hosts are only used in Tempest negative tests and should arguably be moved out of Tempest and into the Nova unit tests (which might already exist).

Documentation Impact

The compute API reference documentation for the os-hosts API will be updated to mention that the API is deprecated at the new microversion. We could also mention the limitations with some of the API, like the power actions only being implemented by some virt drivers, that they are not tested, and that the startup action is not implemented at all. Basically, do not use those ever.

History

Revisions

Release Name

Description

Pike

Introduced