Feature Freeze

Because Oslo does releases on a different schedule from many of the rest of the OpenStack projects, it is helpful to have some modified policies around feature freeze as well.

Problem Description

Oslo wants to respect the feature freeze date that is set for the OpenStack community as a whole, but due to the nature of libraries it can be problematic for us to continue adding new features right up until the official feature freeze.

Proposed Policy

Projects in the Oslo program will observe their own feature freeze, which will occur one week before the overall OpenStack feature freeze and continue until all of the consuming OpenStack projects have made their releases for the cycle. This is a hard freeze, and as such only critical bug fixes should merge during the freeze period.

Freezing early will provide time to release any pending changes in the Oslo libraries before the consuming projects enter feature freeze.

Note that this policy also applies to oslo-incubator. Feature freezing the incubator code means that if a bug in incubator is found by a consuming project, the sync of the fix to that project will not include any new features that may have been added to incubator in the meantime.

Exceptions

This policy will not apply to libraries that have not yet been released. Any in-progress graduation work on those can continue through feature freeze as it will not affect any frozen projects.

Alternatives & History

We could simply observe the overall feature freeze date, but due to library release cycles that may result in new features being released during feature freeze.

Another option would be to not observe feature freeze at all and rely on our release-to-release compatibility requirements to handle any issues. This would not only make it more likely for us to release a buggy version of a lib during feature freeze, but it should be unnecessary as our consumers would be unable to implement any new features exposed in Oslo libraries during that time anyway.

Implementation

Author(s)

Primary author:
bnemec
Other contributors:
dhellmann

Milestones

One week before OpenStack feature freeze

Work Items

  • Make an announcement on the mailing list on the date of Oslo feature freeze

Revision History

Revisions
Release Name Description
  Introduced

Note

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/legalcode