Persist libvirt instance storage metadata

Persist libvirt instance storage metadata

https://blueprints.launchpad.net/nova/+spec/libvirt-instance-storage

Libvirt ephemeral storage layout is currently mostly inferred based on the local configuration of the compute node. This is problematic in several cases. In edge cases, it has been the recent cause of several severe security vulnerabilities. It also makes storage configuration hard or impossible to vary between compute nodes in the same installation, or over time after installation. By persisting storage metadata of a particular instance explicitly we make its configuration unambiguous and simple to understand, and therefore less vulnerable to security issues. We also make it possible to unambiguously represent multiple storage configurations within a single installation. While we don’t make the necessary changes to correctly handle multiple storage configurations, by describing them unambiguously we lay a foundation for future work to enable this.

Problem description

There are several problems with the libvirt ephemeral storage code:

  • The code has been expanded beyond its original design with the addition of each new backend type (LVM/RBD/ploop), but has never been redesigned to accomodate these substantially different models.

  • Storage layout is inferred from 2 config variables on the compute node: libvirt.images_type and use_cow_images. An instance which was created on another compute node with different values for these config variables, or which was created before the values of these config variables were changed, will be incorrectly handled. This will lead to failure at best. At worst it will create a security vulnerability.

  • The imagebackend code uses a single method, cache(), to create both disks from glance images, and disks from templates (i.e. blank filesystems or swap disks). These are then handled differently by different backends. Writing to the image cache is done by the individual backends, which use the image cache differently due to their different natures. To do this, backends must differentiate between glance images and templates, but the interface does not permit them to do this directly. The Raw backend greps ‘image_id’ from the argument passed to its template function. The LVM backend uses ‘ephemeral_size’. The Ploop backend uses ‘context’ and ‘image_id’, and independently fetches glance metadata. The cache() interface needs to be changed to reflect its usage.

  • The cache() interface does not provide the backend with any metadata about disk image it is being given to import. Consequently it must either infer it heuristically or inspect it. Both methods are prone to error and potential security bugs. The replacement for cache() must allow the backend to determine in advance the format and size of the disk it is importing.

  • The Raw backend is badly named, as disks using the Raw backend may be either raw or qcow2. The Raw backend first inspects the disk it is importing (see problem above), then writes its format to a local file called disk.info. Storing the format of the disk means that there is no need to inspect the disk at boot time, which prevents a severe security flaw. However, we can do much better than this. disk.info is used inconsistently between the Qcow2 and Raw backends, and other backends do not use it at all. It is also local to a single compute node, so cannot be used to determine storage layout during a migration.

Use Cases

Developer: Reduce bugs, in particular security bugs, by creating a single, canonical, persistent repository for disk metadata.

Developer: Enable future backend development work by removing poorly understood heuristics and tight coupling.

Developer: By storing disk layout per instance rather than compute node, enable the future development of features to:

  • migrate between disk layouts.

  • implement different per-instance storage policies (e.g. SSD vs spinning rust).

  • track the process of upgrading disk layouts during an upgrade.

Proposed change

We need to make 2 changes:

1 Split the cache() method into 2 separate methods:

create_from_image(image_id), and create_from_func(func, size).

2 Create a persistent record of a disk’s layout before creating the disk. This

includes at least: the backend in use, disk format, and size. This persistent record must be extensible so that, for example, in the future we can specify multiple local storage locations for qcow2 disks, and choose between them.

The first change involves a substantial refactoring of libvirt’s imagebackend module. This should be achieved with a minimum of functional change.

The second change depends on the first. With the first change in place we have enough context when creating a disk to know how big it is, what format it is, and where it should go. We will implement library code which persists this information for the disk, and then calls out to the relevant backend. It will be stored in a virt driver specific field we will add to BlockDeviceMapping: driver_info. Higher level code will treat this as an opaque blob. The libvirt driver will treat it as a serialised versioned object: LibvirtDiskMetadata. LibvirtDiskMetadata will initially contain the metadata mentioned above.

Alternatives

There are undoubtedly other ways to achieve this. The important principal, though, is that the driver should have a persistent, unambiguous record of how an instance’s storage is laid out. I have picked this one.

Data model impact

A driver_info column will be added to the block_device_mapping table with type Text. The column will be nullable, and will initially be unpopulated. It will not be indexed, or have any associated constraints.

The column will be populated by the driver when performing any operation on a disk and it is found to be unpopulated. It will initially take values based on the current behaviour of the driver.

REST API impact

None

Security impact

This change does not directly impact security, but by simplifying an area of code which has been the source of several severe security bugs it should indirectly improve security. Specifically, by ensuring we always know the format of a virtual disk we should never have to perform insecure format inspection.

Notifications impact

None

Other end user impact

None

Performance Impact

When reading block device mappings for the driver, we will need to additionally pull back driver_info, which will add some small overhead. More significantly, with this change the driver will update the BlockDeviceMapping object for each disk during boot and similar operations. We should be able to reduce the impact of this update for instances with multiple disks by batching them in a single update to a BlockDeviceMappingList object. This would require only one round trip to conductor.

Other deployer impact

None

Developer impact

The change adds a driver_info field to the BlockDeviceMapping object, and uses it in the libvirt driver. Other drivers may also use this field, although this change does not define how they should do that.

Implementation

Assignee(s)

Primary assignee:

mbooth-9

Other contributors:

None

Work Items

  • Refactor libvirt.imagebackend to split up cache()

  • Add persistent metadata storage in BlockDeviceMapping

Dependencies

None

Testing

Primarily, this should introduce no functional change. Its purpose is to enable future change. Consequently, to the greatest extent possible, all existing tests should continue to run with a minimum of change.

Tempest should require no changes.

Unit tests will likely have significant churn due to changing internal interfaces, but the scenarios covered should be at least the same as previously.

Note that Jenkins currently only tests the Qcow2 and Rbd(ceph) backends in the gate. All current libvirt tempest jobs run by Jenkins use the default Qcow2 backend except gate-tempest-dsvm-full-devstack-plugin-ceph, which uses Rbd. We additionally coverage of the ploop backend in check-dsvm-tempest-vz7-exe-minimal run by Virtuozzo CI. This means that we currently have no gate coverage of the Raw and Lvm backends.

Documentation Impact

None

References

None

History

None

Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License

Except where otherwise noted, this document is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License. See all OpenStack Legal Documents.

nova-specs