RPC and VersionedObject Compatibility

https://blueprints.launchpad.net/cinder/+spec/rpc-object-compatibility

The following proposal is to enable rolling upgrade in cinder. More specifically, it allows cinder services (cinder-api, cinder-scheduler, cinder-backup, and cinder-volume) to be updated one at a time and yet still be operational (only one service is taken down for upgrade instead of all). It follows the rolling upgrade feature in nova, using oslo_versionedobjects, but is different in that there is no indirection API. Instead, RPC versions and objects are going to be pinned to a backwards compatible version and later switched to the latest version when all services are upgraded.

Problem description

Today, when a new milestone is released, it can take quite a while to upgrade all the service within an OpenStack cloud to the latest release. Upgrade involves: synching the database to the latest schema and updating each distributed cinder service. This process can take down part of a cloud for a few hours or possibly longer. Operators ideally like to reduce the down time for their cloud when upgrading to the next release.

Use Cases

As an operator, I want to individually upgrade each service to the latest release, but not take down my entire cloud in the process.

Proposed change

There are a couple of problems with upgrading a distributed service such as cinder: 1. The content sent over RPC can change. 2. The RPC interface itself can change, i.e. new keyword arguments.

To address these problems, the content can be made backwards compatible using oslo_versionedobject, and the RPC interface can be pinned to a specific version until all components within cinder are upgraded.

The implementation is as follows: 1. When a service starts, it registers the RPC and object versions it knows about, i.e. minimum and latest versions.

2. On upgrade, the admin upgrades each individual cinder service. When the service starts, it knows that there is a newer version, but continue to run at the current/pinned version indicated in the database. The database is the source of truth for which version a service should run.

There is no specific order for which cinder service should be upgraded first. The database keeps track of the RPC and object versions that the service should be using. The service will continue to use the specific versions until an all clear is given by the admin (see below).

3. While other cinder services are being upgraded, the service has to constantly check the database for the current and available RPC and object versions. Since constantly accessing the database is a major performance hit, it can be minimized by caching a copy of the table tracking the versions. The copy will be valid for a few seconds (e.g. 5 seconds), and it is refreshed afterwards. This at least brings down the number of database access for each RPC call.

A flag is used internally within the service to track if it should run in backwards compatibility mode (e.g. BACKWARD_COMPAT_MODE), i.e. RPC and object versions to be made backwards compatible. If the current version is lower than the available version, then BACKWARD_COMPAT_MODE is set to true. Otherwise, it is set to false. There is logic in each service’s rpcapi.py to set the correct keyword arguments for a given RPC version. There is also logic in the objects being sent over RPC to set the correct attributes for a given target version. More specifically, each object should be made backwards compatible by a call to it’s own obj_make_compatible(), which transforms the object to a given target version.

4. Once all cinder services are upgraded, the admin executes a “cinder-manage version upgrade” to switches the current/pinned versions to the latest available versions. This command basically updates the service_versions table in the cinder database. Since the current version is equal to the available version, BACKWARD_COMPAT_MODE is set to false and each RPC call no longer needs to check the database.

By using the BACKWARD_COMPAT_MODE flag, each cinder service only needs to be restarted once (i.e. once for upgrade). Once the flag is turned off, each cinder service can dynamically switch over to using the new RPC and object versions.

Once most of the cinder internals are switched to use oslo_versionedobject and the RPC compatibility layer (this feature) is added, rolling upgrade should be supported (hopefully in the Liberty release and onwards). Rolling upgrade should be limited to two releases older. For example, release N would be backwards compatible with release L (Liberty) and M, and release O would be backwards compatible with release M and N. For a host/service that is too old, it should raise an exception on startup and not be allowed to start.

Alternatives

The upgrade process can be left as-is, where all the components must be taken down and upgraded at the same time. Some cloud operators, e.g. Rackspace, have automated their upgrade procedure to a few minutes. However, other cloud operators have a need for this feature.

Data model impact

A new table, called service_versions, would be created to track the RPC and object versions. The schema would be as follows:

service_versions = Table(
‘service_versions’, meta, Column(‘created_at’, DateTime(timezone=False)), Column(‘updated_at’, DateTime(timezone=False)), Column(‘deleted_at’, DateTime(timezone=False)), Column(‘deleted’, Boolean(create_constraint=True, name=None)), Column(‘id’, Integer, primary_key=True, nullable=False), Column(‘service_id’, String(length=255)), Column(‘rpc_current_version’, String(length=36)), Column(‘rpc_available_version’, String(length=36)), Column(‘object_current_version’, String(length=36)), Column(‘object_available_version’, String(length=36)), mysql_engine=’InnoDB’

)

The service_id is service name + host. The *_current_version is the version a service is currently running and pinned at. The *_available_version is the version a service knows about and (if newer) could upgrade to.

REST API impact

None

Security impact

None

Notifications impact

None

Other end user impact

A new command, i.e. “cinder-manage version upgrade”, would be introduced to switch the cinder services to use the latest RPC and object versions.

Performance Impact

During upgrade, before a call is sent over RPC, it would have to check if it needs to be backwards compatible. If so, it would need to massage the RPC interface and object to be backwards compatible. It would incur a cost on performance because there would be extra database calls to find the current and available RPC and object versions. Since accessing the database before each RPC call is a major performance hit, it can be minimized by caching a copy of the table tracking the versions. The copy will be valid for a few seconds (e.g. 5 seconds), and it is refreshed afterwards. This at least brings down the number of database access for each RPC call. Once upgrade is done and all services are upgrade to the latest versions, there would no longer be a need to check the database.

Other deployer impact

None

Developer impact

Any new changes to the RPC interface within cinder-api, cinder-scheduler, cinder-volume, or cinder-backup would have to add to the backwards compatible layer from when this feature merges and onwards. Also, any new changes to an object, e.g. volume, snapshot, etc., must be made backwards compatible in the object’s obj_make_compatible().

Implementation

Assignee(s)

Primary assignee:
thang-pham
Other contributors:
DuncanT (who thought of the feature)

Work Items

  • Create service_versions table to track RPC and object versions.
  • Register each cinder service’s RPC and object versions on startup.
  • Create RPC compatibility layer in each cinder component’s rpcapi.py to

massage the object and RPC interface before it is sent over RPC.

  • Create a “cinder-manage version upgrade” CLI to switch each cinder service

to use the latest versions.

Dependencies

  • oslo_versionobjects for volumes, backups, service, consistency_group,

quota need to be merged so that objects can be made backwards compatible.

Testing

Ideally, there should be a rolling upgrade test within tempest (e.g. grenade) to test basic RPC and object pinning between different releases. However, such testing would only apply to release M and onwards because most of the oslo_versionedobject and RPC compatibility layers are not in previous releases.

Documentation Impact

It should be documented that operators can upgrade cinder components individually, without taking down the entire cloud. At the end of the process, a “cinder-manage version upgrade” must be executed to switch the services to use the latest RPC and object versions.